Guaranteed UL or IUL? Keep the Guarantee and Invest the Difference
For people who want lifetime coverage but won't bet that index credits will outrun an IUL's higher policy costs. Buy a guaranteed universal life policy, invest what you save, and see what your family would receive either way.
Built on two real carrier illustrations, not made-up rates
See what your family receives at every age, side by side
Test the IUL at its illustrated, alternate and guaranteed values
Set your own return, fees, taxes and saving habits
Placing life insurance since 1999Top-rated carriers comparedNo broker feesLicensed in most states
The calculator
Run the Numbers on a Real Case
Pick an example, choose how the IUL performs, and set your own investing assumptions. Everything updates as you go.
Example:
The difference
Family gets: GUL path
Family gets: IUL
Coverage guaranteed to
What your family would receive if you died at that age
The GUL pays its guaranteed death benefit and your family keeps the investment account. The IUL pays its death benefit, which depends on how the policy has performed.
GUL death benefit + investment accountIUL death benefit
Money you could use while you are living
The investment account after tax on gains, plus any guaranteed surrender value in the GUL, next to the IUL's net surrender value. Both sides pay the same amount out of pocket every month.
GUL + investment account, after taxIUL net surrender value
What the extra IUL premium has to earn
Return you would need
Discipline you would need
What the math leaves out
IUL credits are not a straight line.The illustration assumes the same rate every year. Real index credits move between the floor and the cap, and carriers can change caps.
IUL charges can rise.Cost of insurance and policy charges are not locked in. The guaranteed column shows the policy if charges go to their maximum.
A GUL guarantee has rules.Pay late or skip a premium and the guarantee can shorten or end. The premium needs to go out on time, every time.
IUL cash value has tax advantages.It grows tax-deferred and can be reached through policy loans. The investment account may be taxed along the way.
IUL is flexible.You can raise, lower or skip premiums within limits, and many policies include living benefits. A GUL is built to do one job.
Investing takes follow-through.The GUL plan only works if the difference really gets invested and left alone.
Year-by-year numbers
See this comparison with your own numbers
These examples use real illustrations, but yours will differ with your age, health and coverage amount. We run the GUL and IUL illustrations side by side for you, from the top-rated carriers, with no broker fees.
We will send the numbers on your screen to your inbox so you can come back to them. We never sell or share your information.
How it works
Lifetime Coverage Without Betting on Index Credits
How buy GUL and invest the difference works
Price the same lifetime coverage two ways: as a guaranteed universal life policy and as an indexed universal life policy.
Buy the GUL. It costs less because it is built to guarantee the death benefit, not to build cash value.
Invest the monthly savings in an account you own and control.
You end up with a death benefit that does not depend on index performance, plus savings that sit outside the policy. The calculator shows how those savings compare with the IUL's cash value under each column of the illustration.
Who each approach tends to fit
GUL and investing tends to fit people who want permanent coverage they do not have to monitor, and who would rather not count on index credits to outrun policy charges.
IUL tends to fit people who want cash value and flexibility inside the policy, value tax-deferred growth and loan access, and are comfortable reviewing the policy as caps and charges change.
Guaranteed universal life is permanent insurance with a level premium and a death benefit guaranteed to a set age, often 100 or 121, as long as premiums are paid on time. It builds little or no cash value.
How is IUL different from GUL?
Indexed universal life credits interest based on a market index, with a floor and a cap, and is designed to build cash value. Its charges and credits are not fully guaranteed, so results depend on how the policy performs.
Is the IUL illustration a prediction?
No. An illustration shows what happens if one assumed rate is credited every year. The guaranteed column shows the contract's worst case. Actual results will fall somewhere else.
What happens if I miss a GUL premium?
A late or missed premium can shorten or end the guarantee. Many people set the premium on automatic payment for that reason. Ask how the catch-up rules work on any GUL you consider.
Can I do some of each?
Yes. Some people cover their core need with a GUL and add a smaller IUL for cash value, or the reverse. It does not have to be all one or the other.
Are these real numbers?
Yes. The premiums and policy values come from carrier illustrations run in July 2026 at Preferred non-tobacco rates. The investment account figures are hypothetical and use the assumptions you set.
Plain English ยท No pressure
See GUL and IUL Side by Side for Your Age
We run both illustrations from the top-rated carriers, show you exactly what is and is not guaranteed, and never charge broker fees.
This calculator is for education only. It is not a life insurance policy illustration, a quote, or an offer of coverage, and it is not investment, tax or legal advice. Policy values shown for the IUL are taken from a carrier illustration dated July 2026 and are not guaranteed unless labeled guaranteed; they assume premiums are paid as illustrated and that no loans or withdrawals are taken. Actual premiums, values, charges and guarantees depend on underwriting and appear only in the insurance company's illustration and contract.
Investment account figures are hypothetical. Returns are not guaranteed and you can lose money. Tax treatment is simplified: gains in the investment account are taxed once at the rate you choose when cashed out, and are shown untaxed when passed to heirs. IUL values are shown before any tax. Life insurance death benefits are generally received income-tax free. Talk with a licensed professional about your own situation.
Calculator by Brandon D. Sears, CLU, ChFC, placing permanent and term life insurance for clients since 1999. Compare Life Insurance, NPN 17946970.
Still weighing term against permanent coverage? If you haven't settled that question yet, start here: Term vs. Whole Life: Which One Fits Your Family (With Real Numbers) compares the two side by side with real 2026 numbers before you drill into which permanent structure fits.